Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs (2023)

Note: This article may contain affiliate links. Please click here to check out the full disclaimer.
Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs

Irrespective of their cutesy exterior and affectionate expressions, every dog is a pack animal. This innate pack mentality can often lead to complex behavioral patterns and stubborn traits that may require technology for effective management, such as a training collar. However, selecting the best training collar for stubborn dogs can ensure smoother training, forming the basis for our comprehensive review today.

SportDOG FieldTrainer 425XS 

When we say the best training collar for stubborn dogs must offer versatility to match your pet’s intelligence and determination, we refer to products like the SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425XS. This device targets explicitly stubborn pets, offering broader static stimulation levels for dogs unfazed by standard intensities.

SportDOG FieldTrainer 425XS

Key Features:

  • Optimized for Stubborn Pets: A broad range of static stimulations, specifically for stubborn pets.
  • Range: 500 yards of signal coverage.

Pros and Cons:

  • Designed mainly for stubborn dogs.
  • Offers an array of static stimulation levels.
  • Price may be a limiting factor.
  • It might not be the best collar for small or sensitive dogs.

SportDOG WetlandHunter 425X 

The SportDOG WetlandHunter 425X Remote Training Dog Collar is a stellar option for owners who enjoy training their pets in expansive terrains. This lightweight collar provides 500 yards of signal coverage, perfect for outdoor environments.

SportDOG WetlandHunter 425X 

Key Features:

  • Distance: It offers great coverage with a range of up to 500 yards.

Pros and Cons:

  • Excellent range of up to 500 yards.
  • Perfect for open-field environments.

  • Relatively higher price point.

ET-300 Mini Educator 1/2 Mile Remote Trainer

The technologically advanced ET-300 deploys innovative methods to make the training process more bearable for our furry friends. It introduces a strong but non-shocking tapping sensation that helps correct your pet’s behavior.


Key Features:

  • Advanced Stimulation Method: The e-collar employs a tapping sensation more intense than standard vibration, promoting better response.
  • Half a mile range.

Pros and Cons:

  • Advanced technology for competent training.
  • Provides a strong but non-shocking tapping sensation.
  • Amazing range.
  • Pricier than other similar products.

Bousnic Dog Shock Collar

The Bousnic Dog Shock Collar is perfect for those lucky owners of multiple dogs. This product aids in managing several pets with one device, making it one of the best training collars for stubborn dogs that caretakers must consider.

Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs

Key Features:

  • Multiple Communication Modes: The device employs beep, vibration, and shock modes to effectively communicate with your pet.

Pros and Cons:

  • Designed for multiple dogs.
  • Includes three modes for efficient interaction.
  • It’s not the best option for smaller or overly sensitive breeds.

Halo Collar

One of the best training collars for stubborn dogs in the market, bearing nifty features, is the Halo Collar. This collar incorporates GPS tracking capabilities and offers smart fences for your pets, pushing the technological boundaries of practical dog training.

Halo Collar

Key Features:

  • GPS Tracking: The integrated GPS tracking systems enable you to closely watch your pet’s movement.
  • Smart Fences: These collars can set custom boundary fences to limit your pet’s movement, establishing safe and off-limit zones.

Pros and Cons:

  • The collar includes GPS tracking.
  • Perfect for curbing pet’s roaming habits.
  • It offers limited training controls.
  • Requires a consistent GPS signal for practical functionality.

Comparison Chart

Dog CollarRangeModes of StimulationLevels of StimulationWaterproofBattery Life
SportDOG FieldTrainer 425XS Stubborn Dog Remote Trainer500 yardsBeep, Vibrate, ShockLow to High (Increased Static Stimulation)YesLong-lasting
SportDOG WetlandHunter 425X Remote Training Dog Collar500 yardsBeep, Vibrate, ShockLow to HighYesLong-lasting
ET-300 Mini Educator1/2 Mile to 1 MileBeep, Vibrate, ShockLow to HighYesLong-lasting
Bousnic Dog Shock Collar1000 feetBeep, Vibrate, Shock16 levelsYesRechargeable with decent life
Halo CollarN/A (GPS based)Feedback (Vibration and Static)Custom levelsYesRechargeable with decent life

Frequently Asked Questions
Q. Is ET-300 Mini Educator suitable for first-time dog owners?A. The ET-300 Mini Educator incorporates advanced stimulation methods, which some first-time dog owners might perceive as complex. It can be an excellent tool if you’re open to learning and using sophisticated technology.
Q. Can I use only one dog for the Bousnic Dog Shock Collar?A. The Bousnic Dog Shock Collar can be used for a single dog. However, it’s designed to control multiple dogs, which can make it a valuable investment should you decide to expand your fur family in the future.
Q. Does the Halo Collar function without a GPS signal?A. The Halo Collar requires a consistent GPS signal for efficient functionality, especially when using advanced features such as GPS tracking and smart fences. With a GPS signal, some of the advanced characteristics may be expanded.
Q. Can SportDOG Brand FieldTrainer 425XS Stubborn Dog Remote Trainer be used for non-stubborn dogs?A. Yes, it can technically be used, but it’s designed specifically for stubborn dogs with higher levels of static stimulation. Opting for a collar more aligned with your pet’s nature and requirements might be better.

Essential Tips for Using Collars on Stubborn Dogs

Training a stubborn dog can be challenging, especially for first-time pet owners. However, you can reign in your pet’s unruly behavior with perseverance, dedication, and the right tools, such as a well-suited training collar. This article explores essential tips to help you effectively use training collars to curtail stubborn dogs’ temperaments.

Tip 1: Ensure a Perfect Fit

Proper collar fit is crucial when training stubborn dogs. Too loose, the dog may not feel the intended stimulation, rendering your training efforts futile. Too tight, and the dog may experience discomfort or even pain. Striving for an optimal balance of snugness ensures practical training and the dog’s well-being.

Follow these steps to guarantee the correct fit for your chosen collar:

Place two fingers under the collar band when fastened, ensuring comfortable spacing between the collar and your dog’s neck.

Regularly check the collar’s condition, looking for signs of wear, tear, or loosening.

Tip 2: Introduce the Collar Gradually

Equip your dog with the collar for a few days before activating the training mode, allowing them to acclimate to the new accessory. This period permits your pet to associate the collar with leisure rather than discomfort, laying the groundwork for future training sessions.

Tip 3: Choose the Right Training Modes

Most training collars embody communication modes, such as beep, vibration, or static stimulation. Begin with the least invasive method – often an audible tone – and gradually progress to vibration or static stimulation, if necessary. Significantly, advancing to more robust stimulation modes should be based on the individual dog’s temperament and responsiveness. Avoid overstimulation, as it can be counterproductive to the training process.

Tip 4: Use Consistent Commands

Dogs respond best to consistent verbal or non-verbal commands when being trained. When using a collar, pair the stimulation with a designated command consistently. Combining training techniques fosters quicker responses from your pet and reinforces the collar’s efficacy.

Tip 5: Positive Reinforcement

Remember that training collars supplement the dog training process, not serve as the exclusive component. Utilizing positive reinforcement – like treats, praise, and affection – alongside training collars can significantly improve results and encourage healthy responses from your four-legged companion.

Tip 6: Start Training Early and Set Clear Boundaries

Begin training your pet as early as possible, enabling your dog to recognize and adhere to clear boundaries. With stubborn dogs, early and consistent training instills obedience and respect for established rules.

Tip 7: Be Patient and Persistent

Patience is vital when training stubborn dogs. Remember that these strong-willed pets often require additional time and effort to understand and comply with commands. A steadfast approach ensures efficient training and yields long-lasting results.


Finding the best training collar for stubborn dogs can be overwhelming, especially considering the vast number and the technological complexity of options available. However, carefully assessing your pet’s characteristics and individual training needs can be instrumental in guiding you to the perfect product. Remember, training stubborn dogs requires patience, consistency, and the right tools. 

If you enjoyed our Best Training Collar for Stubborn Dogs article, check out this new Exo Drones Review.

Fun Reviewer